God Takes Sides….or When Karl Barth Was Right

 God takes sides.

I was talking to an adult member of my church yesterday about the fight over the debt limit.  At some point I said “well God has already taken sides and I am not sure it is being voiced.”  I went on to say I have no divinely ordained policy prescriptions but scripture is clear descriptively about what God celebrates and abhors in a nation.  The conversation was a bunch of fun and at the end of my Baptist Bible-flippin tour of justice she said, “Wow I had no idea. You should preach that sometime.”  After that I decided I should at least post a blog and say explicitly….God takes sides.

God takes the side of the oppressed, marginalized, impoverished and excluded. God is for them.  God is also against the oppressors, violators, full and power wielders.  Pharaoh knows this to be the case, the Prophets proclaimed, and Jesus’ Mom put it to song.  A little attention to scripture and one quickly sees that the actual material reality of people is a preoccupation of God.  In fact God did not mind legislating the redistribution of land, forgiveness of debt, and imposing upon Israel’s elite the necessity of a social safety net.  There was even this dude named Jesus who told a crazy parable about God judging nations for failing to take these national obligations seriously while getting the religious vocabulary correct.

I know we don’t like the idea of God taking sides.  It gets most people who go to most churches mad, at least in America, because we know we are likely among the most full, wealthy, and powerful people this planet has ever seen.  Yet the church and its leaders often edit, soft pedal, and nuance their way around these divine calls for material transformation.  People like me are scared to say something because we know we usually suck at changing our own patterns and feel powerless to change the suicidal system we were born into but for those who spend their life studying the Christian faith this call is pretty clear.

Now I could go on a good rant now about how the present economic showdown demonstrates how economism has become the one true religion of the state that binds both political parties together or how the American church is so impotent that demonstrating less regard for the poor is a means to securing their support….but then I might get out of hand fast. So instead here are two quotes from the 20th century’s most famous orthodox theologians….not progressive, liberal, social gospelers, feminist, or liberation theologians….Barth and Bonhoeffer were not interested in those games, loved some Trinity, didn’t need to put a word between Jesus Christ (ex. Jesus as the Christ), and had no trouble lecturing on eschatology.  Hope you get the idea – the 20th century’s orthodox articulators knew the God of Israel who was incarnate in Jesus took sides and I think they could help us out today…..and of course they can’t get run out of town.

God always takes His stand unconditionally and passionately on this side and on this side alone: against the lofty and on behalf of the lowly; against those who already enjoy right and privilege and on behalf of those who are denied it and deprived of it….The Command of God is a call for the championing of the weak against every kind of encroachment on the part of the strong. – Karl Barth

Bonhoeffer here describes the place from which the church should examine and assess a situation, the place from which one can come to see reality as a Christian…

It remains an experience of unmatched value that we have learned to see the great events of history from the underside, from the perspective of the eliminated, the suspect, the abused, the powerless, the oppressed, and the ridiculed, in short, from the perspective of the suffering.

How would our present economic impasse and the conflict and conversations around it be different if this divine command was on our hearts?  How would the budget negotiations, taxes, spending, and debt appear from the perspective of America’s underside?

What would it take for the church and its leaders to admit we really to suck at being faithful both in our own material existence and in our fidelity to God’s dream for the world in our church leadership?

If you enjoy all the Homebrewed Christianity Podcasts,
there are two ways you can support our work.
Jiles Maples
Jiles Maples

Try living in the world today without a job. To create good jobs, capitalists require a reliable legal system and property rights. Enlightened capitalism is the fairest and most liberating economic system in the history of the world. Total theocracies have a horrible track record. Bill Gates has done more for others by building his wealth than most of the major denominations in the U.S. Look at the jobs Microsoft has created, not to mention the Gates Foundation. indeed, God offers much for the poor; His capitalists create the means of a decent livelihood.


Dude, stop hating on all my people. I've worked hard to make the orphans, widows, poor, and suffering invisible to most of those politicians and now you come and want to pull my special invisibility cloak off that? I've worked for centuries to root them in economics as the most important thing evah! Don't be dividing people with all your class warfare drivel. My worthy opponent just doesn't get Laffer curves and Supply side. All that squawking about the poor? Pssst. We gotta country to run here boy. Now, I need to get back and put some more lies in people's mouths.

Justin Bowman
Justin Bowman

Spot on brother! So true, was thinking along similar lines last night while putting together a play kitchen for my daughter and listening to the commentary on both Obama and Boehner's press conferences. I don't know what I was cussing at more: Political partisanship, press and media pundents, or that damn play kitchen. this needs to be said, Tripp. This is part of the message of Christ and the Kingdom. IMHO, the main gist/message. I think that (combining with Tad's recent post on evangelical-can't repost link on phone) part of being evangelical is getting this very specific message out, even if it makes people uncomfortable and crosses into the political realm. I remember polling the youth and adults at my last church on subjects they wanted to talk about, and no joke, several put down "not about things like suffering and hurting. That makes me sad.". May I mention that a good majority of the church is very affluent. I was at a loss for words. I wanted and should have responded with, yeah well reality and the world makes us sad sometimes, but that is part of following Christ: to get into those sad areas of life and make some changes. One will never begin to truly understand Christ and the kingdom until they embrace what Christ was about... No matter how uncomfortable it makes us. Great topic Tripp. Thanks for posting this! Peace Justin